The Sherborne Bone is one of archaeology’s most delicious deceptions. A fragment of carved animal rib. A supposed Ice Age masterpiece. And behind it all , possibly a pair of mischievous schoolboys with a bone to pick. This story has everything: a Victorian scientist fooled by a crude fake, decades of bitter academic argument, and a mystery that science couldn’t fully crack for nearly 80 years. Even today, we don’t know exactly who carved it. We may never know. And that’s what makes this case so deeply, wonderfully strange.
The Discovery of the Sherborne Bone
It was October 1911. Two students at Sherborne School in Dorset , Philip Grove and Arnaldo Cortesi , walked into their science master’s office. They handed Eliot Steel a fragment of animal rib. On it was scratched the image of a horse’s head.
Steel was intrigued. He sent the bone to Arthur Smith Woodward at the Natural History Museum in London. Woodward was one of Britain’s most respected paleontologists. He studied the engraving carefully. In 1914, he published his findings. He declared it an authentic Palaeolithic artifact , possibly 10,000 years old or more.
The timing felt electric. The engraving looked strikingly similar to the Robin Hood Cave Horse, a famous Ice Age carving from Derbyshire first published in 1877. Woodward thought the Sherborne find actually proved the Robin Hood Cave Horse was genuine. At that time, some experts suspected the Derbyshire carving was itself a fake. Now, here was apparent confirmation from a completely different site.
The academic world buzzed with excitement. A prehistoric horse engraving, found in the rubble of a Dorset quarry by schoolboys. It seemed almost too perfect.
It was.
There’s a detail that makes this story stranger still. A former student named Ross Jefferson later claimed that Cortesi had been about to throw the bone into a fire. Jefferson said he stopped him. He told Cortesi to show it to Steel instead. Was that a moment of genuine discovery , or the final act of a carefully planned trick?
Decades of Doubt: Who Faked the Sherborne Bone?
Related article: Lenin Was a Mushroom: The Soviet TV Hoax That Fooled a Nation
Almost immediately, cracks appeared. Not just in the bone , but in the story.
William Sollas, a prominent Oxford geologist, didn’t mince words. He called it “a forgery perpetrated by some school boys.” That was a bold accusation. Woodward pushed back. The argument simmered for years.
Then in 1926, things got weirder. A man named Charles Bayzard came forward. He had worked as a laboratory assistant to Sollas. Before that, he had worked at Sherborne School. Bayzard claimed that students there had told him directly , the bone was a fake. They made it to trick Steel.
Steel fired back. He said Bayzard’s story was itself a hoax. Cortesi, by then working as a journalist for the New York Times, denied everything. He insisted the bone was genuine. Grove couldn’t speak for himself. He had been killed during the First World War.
The family of Grove maintained that he had always believed the find was real. That added a layer of tragedy to the whole affair. A young man who died in the trenches, possibly carrying the secret of an elaborate prank , or possibly the truth of a genuine discovery.
In 1957, scientist Kenneth Oakley ran a fluorine absorption test on the bone. The results were consistent with an Upper Palaeolithic date. That seemed to vindicate Woodward. But in 1980, researcher Ann Sieveking studied the bone’s cracks under magnification. She concluded the engraving had been made after the cracks formed. That pointed strongly toward a modern fake.
The Robin Hood Cave Horse, which appears to have inspired the hoax, had been widely published and reproduced by the late 1800s. Any clever student with access to a library could have copied it.
The Sherborne Bone Finally Gets Its Answer
Science eventually settled the argument. Sort of.
In 1994, C.B. Stringer and a team of researchers performed radiocarbon dating on the bone. The results were devastating for believers in its authenticity. The bone dated to the 14th century AD , roughly 700 years old. Not 10,000. Not even close.
The team’s conclusion was blunt: “it now seems inescapable that the Sherborne engraving is a recent fake.”
But here’s where it gets strange again. The bone itself was medieval. The engraving, however, was almost certainly made much later. The design copies the Robin Hood Cave Horse so closely that it must have been carved after 1877 , when that Derbyshire engraving was first published. Someone found an old piece of medieval animal bone and carved a fake prehistoric horse onto it. Then they planted it in a quarry. Then two schoolboys “found” it.
Or did they?
The question of who actually did the carving was never conclusively answered. D’Errico and colleagues suggested the most likely culprits were students at Sherborne School. But no confession ever emerged. No smoking chisel. No deathbed admission.
J.H.P. Gibb, a housemaster at Sherborne School, accepted the radiocarbon findings. The story made national headlines in Britain in late 1995. After 80 years of argument, the Sherborne Bone had been exposed.
The Hoax That Fooled a Generation of Scientists
What makes this case so fascinating isn’t just the forgery. It’s how close it came to permanently rewriting prehistoric history.
Woodward was no fool. He was the same man who authenticated Piltdown Man , which, of course, turned out to be another elaborate hoax. That connection is almost too perfect. The early 20th century was apparently a golden age for fake prehistoric artifacts fooling real prehistoric scientists.
The Sherborne case also raises uncomfortable questions about confirmation bias. Woodward wanted the bone to be real. It supported his existing beliefs about Palaeolithic art in Britain. The Robin Hood Cave Horse needed defending. Here was the perfect evidence. Sometimes, brilliant people see what they want to see.
The unknown forger , likely a bored, clever schoolboy around 1900 , created something that sparked 80 years of academic warfare. Fluorine tests. Microscopic analysis. Radiocarbon dating. Entire careers touched by one carved piece of medieval rib.
There’s something almost admirable about that. And something deeply unsettling. If the fluorine test had been more conclusive. If radiocarbon dating hadn’t existed. The Sherborne Bone might still be sitting in a museum case labeled “authentic Ice Age art.”
How many other fakes are still out there, waiting?
—
Excerpt (under 150 characters):
The Sherborne Bone fooled experts for decades. Discover the strange tale of a fake Ice Age engraving, two schoolboys, and a century-long mystery.



